Reader's Exchange

The art of book reviewing

I've been reading on the job this week--not current fiction of my choice, alas, but dozens and dozens of book reviews.  Distilling a useful critique into a brief paragraph represents such an admirable skill set; I rarely tire of scanning those little gems.  Some phrases seem particularly useful for conveying literary merit.

Lengthy novels, for example, are frequently promoted as "a sweeping tale of..."  I like a good sweeper as much as the next reader but have learned to note who makes that assertion.  When a reviewer elects the description, it generally signifies an ambitious but ultimately satisfying scope.  The identical claim from a publisher may indicate that the writer's reach has exceeded his/her grasp.

Some books "take you into the world of..."  This verbiage prompts me to examine the review more closely: is that setting/premise unique or revelatory--or just obscure?

When a review charitably observes that "the author does manage to...." I anticipate a "but" or "however" a few lines further down the page.

And then there's "unrelentingly", a term that bodes more favorably for comic book heroes than for novelists.  If I ever create a work of fiction, it will likely be deemed "a sweeping tale of unrelentingly inept literary ambition that takes you into the world of first-time publication (in which the author does manage to...")


Shannon McIntire said:

I used to devour book and movie reviews. If I found a work I loved, liked, or even hated, I always wanted to see what others had to say about it. Usually, I would find one that expressed exactly what I thought.

I’ve learned to take reviews with a large grain of salt, though. I’ve found that there is no work I think is superlative that there isn’t someone who vehemently disparages it and no work I find completely worthless that doesn’t have some proponent praising it to the skies.

This hypothetical book of yours sounds like it has everything — a sure fire hit!

# August 21, 2009 10:46 AM
If you would like to comment, you need to join Community Conversations